What’s the Deal with Dual Agency?

Alright, buckle up because dual agency is one of those topics that sounds simple at first but gets more complicated the deeper you dive. And if you’re a new real estate agent, this is one of those “Should I even ask about this?” kind of questions. The answer: Yes, you should. Let’s break it down.

What is Dual Agency?

Dual agency happens when one real estate agent represents both the buyer and the seller in the same transaction. Think of it like being the referee in a game where you’re also playing for both teams. Sounds tricky? It can be.

In a normal real estate deal, you’ve got one agent looking out for the buyer’s interests and another looking out for the seller’s interests. Dual agency? One agent is doing both jobs.

Why Would You Do It?

Let’s get the obvious out of the way: double the commission. That’s one of the biggest reasons agents like dual agency. Instead of splitting the commission with another agent, you get the whole thing to yourself. Cha-ching, right?

But there’s more to it than just the cash grab. Sometimes, in a smaller market or niche transactions, it’s just convenient. Maybe the buyer didn’t have an agent, or the seller specifically asked you to represent both sides. It happens.

The Controversy: Conflict of Interest

Here’s where it gets murky. When you’re in a dual agency situation, how can you truly represent both parties fairly? Each side has different goals—buyers want the lowest price, sellers want the highest. And you’re stuck in the middle. You can’t really advocate for one side without potentially screwing over the other. That’s where the conflict of interest comes in.

A lot of people think dual agency is a bad idea because it’s hard to stay neutral. Even if you try your best to be fair, someone could feel like you weren’t fully in their corner. This is why dual agency is illegal in some states or comes with heavy restrictions.

First, know that disclosure is key. If you’re even thinking about stepping into a dual agency situation, you need to let both parties know upfront. You’ll need their written consent, so they understand exactly what they’re getting into.

And remember: some states straight-up ban dual agency because of that conflict of interest problem. Others have strict rules about how it can be done. So, check with your broker or local real estate commission before you find yourself in hot water.

How to Navigate Dual Agency (If You Must)

If you’re in a state where dual agency is allowed and you find yourself in a situation where it makes sense, here’s how to handle it:

  1. Be Transparent. Explain to both parties what dual agency means, what you can and can’t do, and make sure they’re both on board with it. Don’t downplay it—be clear that you’re acting as a middleman, not an advocate for either side.

  2. Stay Neutral. Your job is to facilitate the deal, not to push for a higher price for the seller or a lower price for the buyer. You’re there to guide the transaction, provide information, and help both parties make informed decisions.

  3. Know When to Walk Away. If you think it’s getting too messy, or if one party starts to feel uncomfortable, don’t be afraid to suggest separate representation. It’s better to lose part of a commission than to end up with unhappy clients (or worse, a lawsuit).

Should You Even Do Dual Agency?

Here’s the honest truth: If you’re a new agent, maybe steer clear for now. Dual agency can be a lot to juggle, especially when you’re still figuring out the basics. Plus, it can get ethically sticky. Some agents swear by it, but many others avoid it because they don’t want the headache.

If you’re curious, ask your broker or a more experienced agent for their take. They’ve probably seen it all and can give you some good advice. But just know, if it feels uncomfortable, there’s no shame in sticking to one side of the deal.

Final Thoughts

Dual agency might seem like a quick way to double your commission, but it comes with its own set of challenges. Between the legal requirements, potential conflicts of interest, and balancing the needs of both parties, it’s not always as easy as it sounds. But hey, that’s why you’re asking the "dumb" questions now, right? Better to know what you’re getting into than to jump in blind.

So next time someone brings up dual agency, you’ll be ready to jump into the conversation. You’ll sound like a pro and, more importantly, make sure you’re doing what’s best for your clients—and your business.

Want to level up even more?
For answers to common real estate questions, check out our Agent Articles.
Want expert insights? Hit up our Agent Bookshelf.
Looking to streamline your game? Check out our Agent Resources.
Not subscribed to our newsletter yet? Do that here.