The Follow-Up Formula: How to Stay Top of Mind Without Being a Pain

Alright, let’s talk follow-up. You know that weird grey area where you’ve already made contact, but the deal isn’t closed yet? That’s where a lot of agents drop the ball. Following up is key, but here’s the catch—you don’t want to be that agent, blowing up someone’s inbox like you’re desperate for a sale. Nope, that’s not the move. The real pros know how to stay top of mind without being annoying. Here’s how you can master the art of follow-up and turn those ‘maybes’ into ‘let’s do this.’

1. The 3-2-1 Method

Here’s a simple system to keep you in check. Follow up three days after the initial contact, two weeks later, and then one month after that. Keeps you consistent without feeling too aggressive. It also gives the lead a little breathing room—people need time to think, especially if they’re making a big decision like buying or selling. But the key is, you’re not ghosting them; you’re staying relevant.

2. Add Value Every Time You Reach Out

Don’t just send a generic, “Hey, just checking in!” message. That’s a fast track to being ignored. Each time you follow up, bring something new to the table. It could be a market update, a new listing, or an interesting stat they might not know. This isn’t about being a pest; it’s about being useful. When people see you as a resource, not just a salesperson, they’ll engage more willingly.

3. Mix Up Your Channels

The follow-up game isn’t limited to just emails or phone calls. Hit them up on different platforms—shoot a quick text, drop a voice note, DM them on social media. People communicate in different ways, and if you show up in more places, you increase your chances of being seen. Just don’t go overboard and start stalking them on every app. Keep it natural.

4. Leverage Social Proof

One of the best follow-up techniques is to share success stories. Send a case study of how you helped another client solve a problem or land their dream home. People trust people, and nothing builds credibility like proof that you can actually deliver. Even better, share a testimonial—let someone else sing your praises for you.

5. Be Brief, Be Bright, Be Gone

Nobody wants to read an essay when you follow up. Keep your messages short, punchy, and to the point. The longer you ramble, the quicker you’ll lose their attention. Hit them with what matters, add some value, and dip. Respect their time, and they’ll respect yours.

6. Know When to Let Go (Temporarily)

If someone’s gone completely cold after a few follow-ups, it might be time to hit pause. Ghosting happens, and it’s not always personal. Give them space, but don’t write them off forever. Set a reminder to check in again down the road. You never know when their situation will change, and you want to be the first agent they think of when they’re ready to move forward.

7. Use the “Just Saw This” Trick

Here’s a little hack—send them something like, “Hey, I just came across this property and thought of you,” or “I just saw this market trend, and I remembered our convo.” It feels more natural and less forced, like you genuinely had them in mind, rather than you just following up because your CRM told you to.

8. Don’t Be Afraid to Ask for the Close

At some point, you’ve got to stop dancing around and get direct. If you’ve followed up a few times and they’re still dragging their feet, it’s okay to ask for the close. Something like, “Hey, we’ve been talking for a while now, and I’d love to help you take the next step. What’s holding you back?” A little nudge could be what they need to finally pull the trigger.

9. Create Urgency (Without Sounding Like a Used Car Salesman)

Urgency is powerful, but it has to be authentic. Don’t just make up fake deadlines or pressure people. Instead, show them real opportunities they might miss out on—like a limited-time interest rate or a hot listing that won’t last. The goal is to help them make a smart decision, not rush them into something they’ll regret later.

At the end of the day, the follow-up game is all about balance. You want to stay in the loop without being overbearing. You want to add value without overselling. The key is to show up consistently, be genuinely helpful, and know when to push and when to back off. Follow-up done right isn’t just about closing deals—it’s about building relationships that lead to even more deals down the line.

Looking to get started?
Need more knowledge bombs? Hit up our Agent Bookshelf. Looking to streamline your game? Check out our Agent Resources. Not subscribed to our newsletter yet? Do that here.